Shutting Down: Our Final Post

It’s been a good run, but unfortunately today we are announcing that Clio’s Current is no longer actively updating. This decision may surprise some readers, but it has been floating around in my head for some time. It’s occurred now for a variety of reasons. Since this is the last post though, let’s talk a bit about what we’ve done since we first launched Clio’s on 1 July 2013.

First – my favourite part of any retrospective – the numbers. According to Wolfram Alpha, it has been 2 years, 3 months, and 13 days since that first post.  Over those 118 weeks, we have made 184 entries, which works out to roughly one post every 4.5 days (we were updating twice a week for the first year and a half). Let’s average our posts out to around 1250 words, so we clock out with about 230,000 words written for Clio’s Current

We received around 50,000 page views over that time from 27,500 readers. The vast majority (19,171) were from Canada, followed by 7,742 Americans, 1,428 from the UK, hundreds from places like Australia, India, France, Germany, and so forth. Though I suspect some of these might be robots. This sounds more impressive until you realize those users are spread over 829 days. We generally received around 200 hits a week, though our average works out to 423 because some weeks we received many more than that.

Our most popular content are posts that were successfully shared on Reddit or StumpleUpon (Twitter gave us consistent hits, but not a large numbers of hits). Our most popular post was shared on Reddit comparing Russia today with Germany in the 1930s, while our most regularly viewed pages over time were from an early attempt to explain history and historiography.  Our lowest posts are in the 20s and 30s for hits.

By no means are these numbers impressive. While low audience numbers is not the reason for Clio’s shutting down, they certainly do not argue in favour of keeping it going. After all, we wrote posts here because we enjoyed testing out how to communicate sometimes-complex historical topics to a general audience. We’ve succeeded and failed many times over, reaching large and small audiences, writing good and bad posts.

As a project for historians, I think Clio’s was a success. I learned a lot about how to spin together a coherent tale in 1500 words. I made decisions about what to add and what to cut. Each week was a chance to write something short, punchy, and historical. Academics projects are seemingly never-ending, and completing a short article every week was rewarding in its own way as a writer. Plus every once in a while, I got to write something crazy.

You might be wondering then, why are we stopping? The short answer is that Clio’s is not as unique as it was when we started. Kirk and I first began writing this blog because we didn’t see any other sites doing quite what we envisioned: connecting past and present for readers to emphasize the importance of historical knowledge and thinking. Today, it’s increasingly evident that ActiveHistory.ca is not only doing this better than we are (and perhaps always were?), they are presenting it to a larger audience with a greater diversity of authors. Today, many popular podcasts and YouTube channels explain history to a general audience. We don’t feel like Clio’s is as innovative as it once was, but that is definitely a good thing.

We decided to end early in the middle of our political history series because the end is the end. It seemed unfair to ask our guest contributors to spend time writing for a blog that was shutting down shortly. We will still have the blog up, even though it will no longer update, as an archive of our efforts over the last two years.

The only way to end our final post is to thank all of those who have contributed and read our work. I’d like to thank my two co-editors, Matt Wiseman and Kirk Goodlet. Kirk founded the site with me, and I can still remember the conversations we had in May-June 2013, often over beer, trying to figure what we could do as historians seeking new audiences and new ways of talking about the past. It was very exciting to launch it and then see how much content we produced. Matt joined our team in Winter 2014, and after Kirk moved on, became the co-editor and primary contributor beside me. We had many talks about ways to expand the site, which were just as invigorating as my original conversations with Kirk. I never quite lost the thrill of seeing it update every week, and I thank them both for the many hours they have devoted to Clio’s. I am sure we will continue working together one way or another in the future.

I’d also like to thank our guest contributors and fellow historians who generously provided posts for us. One of the first was Kellen Kurschinski, who wrote about veterans several times and almost joined the team before moving on to greater things. Madeline Knickerbocker wrote a great piece on the Tsilhqot’in that I wished got more attention than it did. Trevor Ford has written for us several times now, and I think if we kept going, would have joined us as a much-valued regular contributor. His posts were always welcome as they offered explorations of history we never could have discussed on our own. Jocelyn B. Hunt gave us two fascinating and timely posts on Scottish independence during their referendum, and the commemorations of the Magna Carta. Our newest contributor, Laurent Carbonneau recently wrote the most popular post from our political history series, and I am sorry that we will not have the opportunity to have him back.

Finally, a thank you to you, our readers. Some of you have been reading us since the beginning, others might have subscribed via email or Twitter or Facebook and caught the occasional post. While we tried never to be too concerned about reader numbers, I guarantee you I looked every week to see how many had visited our site, what content was popular, and how you were getting here. I am thankful for every share, or mention, or comment we received. Knowing 100 people (or many more some weeks) read your work is a thrill that can’t quite be matched by ordinary publication.

I’d like to specifically thank our friends and families who have put up with seeing Clio’s pop up on Facebook or Twitter every week. Many of you have been our regular readers, and I have had countless conversations about our blog posts with many of you. I have always been better at talking through writing than speaking, so it was wonderful to be able to share our love of history with you.

Considering Important Moments in Canadian Political History

Considering Important Moments in Canadian Political History

Writing an article on significant events in Canadian history is a difficult task for the historian. Although we are supposed to be well-read in topics such as Confederation, Vimy Ridge, universal healthcare, and the 1972 Summit Series, we are taught to apply a critical eye to events and peoples that “represent” what it “means” to be Canadian. The significance of major events should not be overlooked, but historians are cautious to accept “traditional” or “popular” histories that focus too narrowly on select episodes. Certainly, there is much more to Canada’s past than is portrayed in short, made-for-TV Heritage Minutes, to cite just one well-known example. But perhaps professional history in Canada is itself too harsh on many of the topics and themes that seem to resonate with so many people outside the discipline. With this in mind, today’s post takes a brief look at some key moments in Canadian political history that have come to symbolize a nation and its populace.

Read More

Necessity, Ideology, and Federal Party Leaders

Necessity, Ideology, and Federal Party Leaders

Since 1867 Canada has had 22 Prime Ministers in Parliament.  Each party leader has brought their own unique vision to their party that sometimes hindered and other times helped their pursuit of power in Ottawa. In that same time there have been multiple third parties that have taken a completely different path from that of the ruling parties to gain the much coveted Official Opposition status.  And of course behind every third party was a dedicated leader with vision and ideology that shaped their party. Yet the question is how much do these visions and ideologies affect actual federal policy?

Read More

Outside Looking In: Canada's Fringe Parties

Outside Looking In: Canada's Fringe Parties

Although only the Liberals and Conservatives have ever formed government in Canada, our history is riddled with other parties throwing their hats into the ring. Sometimes, these fringe parties have an impact on Canadian governance, but mostly they sat on the sidelines. This week, we discuss some of the “fourth parties” that have sat in the House of Commons.

Read More

Let's Clean House: Early Negative Political Advertising in Canada

Let's Clean House: Early Negative Political Advertising in Canada

For those of us who follow politics closely, the cynicism and shallowness of the modern campaign advertisement strikes us as crass, boorish, and worst of all, boring. A sinister voice intoning dire warnings about a party's opponents, an upbeat song and saccharine delivery of platitudes soothing you into complacency: at this point, we are all well acquainted with the tricks of the trade. The relentless application of the art of advertising, however, is a fairly recent development in the world of Canadian politics.

Read More

Moderate Radicals or Radical Moderates? The History of the New Democratic Party

Moderate Radicals or Radical Moderates? The History of the New Democratic Party

The New Democratic Party has been a popular – but not popular enough – choice for Canadian voters since its creation in 1961. They have never formed government, though in 2011 they were the Official Opposition with 103 of 308 seats, which was quite the rebound from their disastrous 1993 showing of 9 out of 295 seats. They have traditionally wavered between 15 and 30 seats, sometimes playing a pivotal role in influencing minority governments. For most of their history, they were content to be the “conscience of the House” until their recent electoral breakthroughs.

Read More

The Ebb and Flow of Conservatism in Canada: Where will the Tide of Tory Blue Turn Next?

The Ebb and Flow of Conservatism in Canada: Where will the Tide of Tory Blue Turn Next?

Although Canadian Prime Minster Stephen Harper is currently “under the gun” for a declining Canadian economy and as a result of the Mike Duffy trial, the past eight years has witnessed a resurgence of Tory blue in Canada. In light of this recent success, it is the perfect time to consider the ebb and flow of an intriguing and important political institution in Canadian political history.

Read More

The Liberal Party of Canada: The Past is Less Important than the Future

The Liberal Party of Canada: The Past is Less Important than the Future

The Liberals are one of the most popular political parties in Canadian history. Their seemingly hegemonic power, careful electioneering, and (some) luck, has helped them dominate Canada’s political theatre. Undoubtedly, Liberals have greatly shaped the Canada we live in today. In our initial Political History Series post, we examine the ideological system that has guided Canadian Liberals: liberalism.

Read More

Clio’s Perspective on Election 2015: Introduction

Clio’s Perspective on Election 2015: Introduction

This week we are beginning a series at Clio’s Current to coincide with the 2015 Canadian election. For the next ten weeks, we will be writing about various aspects of Canadian political history. For our non-Canadian readers, we hope that you enjoy this extended foray and maybe learn a bit about Canada’s fascinating political history (well, we think it is!). If you want a primer on recent events leading up to the 2015 election, you should check out Paul Wells’ excellent overview in Maclean’s before plunging into the past.

Read More

2015 Election Primer: Politicians and the Media

2015 Election Primer: Politicians and the Media

Over the past week, Prime Minister Stephen Harper met with Governor General David Johnston and received approval to dissolve the Government, kicking off what will be the second longest election campaign in Canadian history. Although each party leader outlined their party’s priorities individually, for many the official campaign began last night with the first election debate. The leaders squared off and today news outlets are filled with detailed coverage and analysis of the event.  Rather than analyze the debate or the performance of each party leader, in today’s post we take a brief look at the history of relations between politicians and the media.

Read More

The Bizarre Case of the Tanganyika Laughing Disease

The Bizarre Case of the Tanganyika Laughing Disease

On 30 January 1962, a girls’ school in Kashasha, twenty-five miles outside of Bukoba on the coast of Lake Victoria in the state of Tanganyika (present day Tanzania), was suddenly afflicted with a bizarre case of spontaneous laughter. Three girls began laughing and couldn’t stop. Stranger still, the laughter spread throughout the school and eventually into surrounding villages. The laughter lasted on average seven days and sometimes as long as six months. By the time the epidemic ended, 14 schools had to be shut down and 1000 people were infected. What happened?

Read More

Searching for Life, Sustaining Life: The Rise of Food History

Searching for Life, Sustaining Life: The Rise of Food History

News dropped this week of NASA’s “discovery” of a new planet outside our solar system, described by scientists as the “closest twin” to Earth found to date. If you haven’t heard the details just yet, a planet dubbed Kepler 452b was discovered using the planet-hunting Kepler Space Telescope. The newly found planet is about 60 per cent larger than Earth, which places it in a category of planets called super-Earth. Early reports suggest that the found planet is rocky and, very excitingly, may have an atmosphere similar to our own and fully capable of holding and producing water – the bloodline of life as we know it.

Read More

We're The Ones That Did It? Canada and the Burning of Washington

We're The Ones That Did It? Canada and the Burning of Washington

For Canadians, a popular retort about the War of 1812 is our supposed role in the burning of the White House. In 1814, British soldiers landed in Washington and looted the American capital. Canadians, in their minor role in the conflict as auxiliary forces, sometimes say that Canadians themselves burned down the White House. Despite any claims you might hear, it was British soldiers behind one of the most notable moments of the war. Where and how did the myth of Canadian involvement appear?

Read More

Racist Attitudes and the Global South

Racist Attitudes and the Global South

When Jenny Horne, a white Republican representative from a town near Charleston, stepped up to the podium this week to address the House of Representatives in South Carolina, her words contributed a passionate moment in the debate that eventually led lawmakers to vote to remove the Confederate battle flag from the State House grounds. “I cannot believe that we do not have the heart in this body,” she said while attempting hold back tears, “to do something meaningful, such as take a symbol of hate off these grounds on Friday.” Referring to the tragic June 17 shootings that killed nine African-American members of a Bible study at a Charleston church, Horne aimed her words directly at house representatives concerned with preserving the historical semblance of the Confederate flag.  “Enough about heritage,” she proclaimed towards flag supporters. When the emotional debate ended early Thursday, the House voted 94-20 to pass the bill to remove the flag.

Read More

Robot Historians and the Future of History

Robot Historians and the Future of History

In a world where technology continues to advance at an incredible pace, each generation is exposed to new and powerful transformations. Facebook, Twitter, and Smartphones were all unimaginable changes to the ordinary person of 1995.  By 2035, maybe we will see an unrecognizable world changed by Virtual Reality, Solar Power, and who knows what else. So what might this incredible future hold for history?

Read More

Looking Back on Magna Carta: 800 Years Wiser by Jocelyn B. Hunt

Looking Back on Magna Carta: 800 Years Wiser by Jocelyn B. Hunt

Newspapers and historical groups have presented much fanfare in the lead-up to 15 June for the 800th anniversary of the signing of Magna Carta (Latin for ‘the Great Charter’). The collective applause for the enduring memory of the Great Charter stands to be challenged as with any other remembered historical document or event. Unlike many revisions which fundamentally alter our modern understanding, such as the tartan (1), the history of Magna Carta can further strengthen its importance in our history and for us today. Today’s post will provide the historical context of Magna Carta’s creation and development as well as investigate the difference between the spirit and letter of the charter’s clauses.

Read More

What Role Do Historians Play in ‘Truth and Reconciliation’?

What Role Do Historians Play in ‘Truth and Reconciliation’?

We are currently in the midst of a national conversation about cultural genocide, recently reaffirmed in the public eye by the Truth and Reconciliation Commission. As regular readers of Clio’s Current can attest, this blog aims to engage with issues of national and international significance. We have written extensively about Aboriginal history, but have yet to discuss the role historians might play in the future. To assess this question, it is necessary to explore some of the issues in Aboriginal history thus far "uncovered" by historians.

Read More

What is Accurate History? Historians vs. Reenactors

What is Accurate History? Historians vs. Reenactors

If you’ve ever visited a historic site or museum around the time of a major anniversary, you’ve probably encountered a historical reenactor. Maybe you were at Fort George in Niagara-on-the-Lake, or Gettysburg, Pennsylvania, or at a D-Day commemoration on 6 June, or any number of hundreds of different re-enactments big and small that take place every year. These historical reenactors share a love of history with historians, though they have vastly different views of it.

Read More

A Fledgling Land: The Perpetual Conflicts in Arab Iraq

A Fledgling Land: The Perpetual Conflicts in Arab Iraq

Last month, the extremist group Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant, or ISIS/ISIL took the Iraqi city of Ramadi. Further compounding this stunning seizure was the extremist group’s capture of the ancient city of Palmyra in Syria, thus gaining control of over half of Syria. As its biggest victory in almost a year, it illustrates that despite western intervention the group is not going away quietly. ISIL was propelled into the news last summer when on the morning of June 11th, the world was stunned to hear that Mosul, Iraq’s second largest city, had fallen to the extremist group in a lightning advance. Since then they have continued to push south and spread their control across the region. Yet what does all of this mean? Factionalism and sectarian rifts are nothing new in the ancient lands that hold tribalism and religion over all other political wants. Iraq, however, was not always Iraq, and the Sunni-Shia rift is not a product of the twentieth century. To understand the issues of ISIL and Iraq today, we must understand the history of this divided region of the world.

Read More

Politicized Scholarship: Exploring Themes in Aboriginal History, Part II

Politicized Scholarship: Exploring Themes in Aboriginal History, Part II

A few weeks ago, we published the first post in a short series examining the origins and evolution of Aboriginal history the Canadian context. We traced some of the more influential works in the field to explore the hold of prominent analytic debates, and explored the contribution of recent studies such as James Daschuk’s Clearing the Plains. Today, we continue our short series with a brief post on the influence of legal affairs and land claims, examining in particular the Mackenzie Valley Pipeline Inquiry and the Hawthorn Report.

Read More